20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] Handling message: [artifact:[type:koji-build-group, builds:[[type:koji-build, id:2415041, task_id:114458006, nvr:grub2-2.06-118.fc39]]], agent:adamwill, re-trigger:false, update:[autokarma:true, autotime:true, stable_karma:3, stable_days:14, unstable_karma:-3, require_bugs:true, require_testcases:true, display_name:, notes:Security fix for CVE-2024-1048
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] , type:security, status:pending, request:testing, severity:medium, suggest:unspecified, locked:false, pushed:false, critpath:true, critpath_groups:core critical-path-anaconda critical-path-apps critical-path-base critical-path-build critical-path-compose critical-path-deepin-desktop critical-path-gnome critical-path-kde critical-path-lxde critical-path-lxqt critical-path-server critical-path-standard critical-path-xfce, close_bugs:true, date_submitted:2024-02-22 15:33:31, date_modified:2024-03-05 20:04:10, date_approved:null, date_testing:null, date_stable:null, alias:FEDORA-2024-097eb22907, test_gating_status:passed, from_tag:null, date_pushed:null, meets_testing_requirements:false, url:https://bodhi.fedoraproject.org/updates/FEDORA-2024-097eb22907, title:grub2-2.06-118.fc39, version_hash:87962bd8b57fcbc518b3f668efbee88fe6d680ca, release:[name:F39, long_name:Fedora 39, version:39, id_prefix:FEDORA, branch:f39, dist_tag:f39, stable_tag:f39-updates, testing_tag:f39-updates-testing, candidate_tag:f39-updates-candidate, pending_signing_tag:f39-signing-pending, pending_testing_tag:f39-updates-testing-pending, pending_stable_tag:f39-updates-pending, override_tag:f39-override, mail_template:fedora_errata_template, state:current, composed_by_bodhi:true, create_automatic_updates:false, package_manager:dnf, testing_repository:updates-testing, released_on:null, eol:2024-11-12, setting_status:null], user:[id:7524, name:nfrayer, email:nfrayer@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:packager], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs]]], comments:[[id:3420911, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update has been submitted for testing by nfrayer. , timestamp:2024-02-22 15:33:31, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3420912, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update's test gating status has been changed to 'waiting'., timestamp:2024-02-22 15:33:34, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3420913, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update's test gating status has been changed to 'waiting'., timestamp:2024-02-22 15:33:34, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3420955, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update's test gating status has been changed to 'failed'., timestamp:2024-02-22 16:09:38, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3421192, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:So, the reason this failed tests is a bit unique. They're failing on a sanity check in the openQA tests: it checks whether the test actually has a newer version of the package installed than is present in the update under test, and if so, it flags that as a problem. *Usually* what that means is that, somehow, a newer package already got pushed stable, and pushing the update-under-test stable would move the package backwards, but that's not how it is in this case.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] In this case, the openQA server base image is actually hacked up to use a grub2 build from a side repo (https://adamwill.fedorapeople.org/grubxfs-repo/ ), which I rather arbitrarily versioned grub2-2.06-118.fc39. So it's higher-versioned than the one in this update, so it triggers the failure.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] The reason why I'm doing that is https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=2259266 (which current affects F39). If I let the openQA server base image use the current stable grub2 package, it doesn't boot because of that bug.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] So...it would make things much easier if this update fixed that bug, is what I'm saying. :P Otherwise I'll have to do a hack like disabling the check just for this update so it can go through.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] I thought that bug was supposed to be getting fixed last week; what's the current status, @nfrayer ?, timestamp:2024-02-22 20:42:05, update_id:591513, user_id:302, bug_feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3421192, bug_id:2256827, bug:[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true]], [karma:0, comment_id:3421192, bug_id:2263036, bug:[bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false]]], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]], [id:3422025, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update has been pushed to testing., timestamp:2024-02-23 02:10:31, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3422085, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:works, timestamp:2024-02-23 04:21:12, update_id:591513, user_id:5881, bug_feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3422085, bug_id:2256827, bug:[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true]], [karma:0, comment_id:3422085, bug_id:2263036, bug:[bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false]]], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:5881, name:geraldosimiao, email:geraldo.simiao.kutz@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ambassadors], [name:fedora-br], [name:advocates], [name:respins-sig]]]], [id:3424424, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:ok here, timestamp:2024-02-24 03:46:34, update_id:591513, user_id:124, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:124, name:filiperosset, email:rosset.filipe@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:packager], [name:provenpackager], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ambassadors], [name:l10n], [name:cvsl10n], [name:fedora-br]]]], [id:3425131, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:Working here OK., timestamp:2024-02-25 01:33:57, update_id:591513, user_id:4756, bug_feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3425131, bug_id:2256827, bug:[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true]], [karma:0, comment_id:3425131, bug_id:2263036, bug:[bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false]]], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:4756, name:nixuser, email:nixuser@mail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs]]]], [id:3425321, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:Works., timestamp:2024-02-25 07:17:15, update_id:591513, user_id:198, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:198, name:bojan, email:bojan@rexursive.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:packager], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs]]]], [id:3425396, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:, timestamp:2024-02-25 10:41:48, update_id:591513, user_id:2240, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:2240, name:frantisekz, email:fzatlouk@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:provenpackager], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:qa-admin], [name:signed_fpca], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:sysadmin], [name:ambassadors], [name:advocates], [name:fedorabugs], [name:qa], [name:ipausers]]]], [id:3426579, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:, timestamp:2024-02-26 13:15:31, update_id:591513, user_id:2935, bug_feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3426579, bug_id:2256827, bug:[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true]], [karma:0, comment_id:3426579, bug_id:2263036, bug:[bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false]]], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:2935, name:imabug, email:eugenemah@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedora-hams]]]], [id:3432681, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:my UEFI Workstation boots fine on Thinkpad P1 gen3, timestamp:2024-03-01 09:35:51, update_id:591513, user_id:411, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:411, name:kparal, email:kparal@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa-tools-sig], [name:proventesters], [name:qa], [name:packager], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:qa-admin]]]], [id:3438439, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:@nfrayer said he would add a fix for the XFS issue, but I don't see it yet., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:57:12, update_id:591513, user_id:302, bug_feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3438439, bug_id:2256827, bug:[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true]], [karma:0, comment_id:3438439, bug_id:2263036, bug:[bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false]]], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]], [id:3438440, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:Given that this is a security fix and doesn't make things worse than they are at present, let's waive the failures and get it pushed stable., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:58:27, update_id:591513, user_id:302, bug_feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3438440, bug_id:2256827, bug:[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true]], [karma:0, comment_id:3438440, bug_id:2263036, bug:[bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false]]], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]], [id:3438443, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update's test gating status has been changed to 'waiting'., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:58:59, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3438444, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update's test gating status has been changed to 'passed'., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:59:00, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3438445, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update can be pushed to stable now if the maintainer wishes, timestamp:2024-03-05 19:59:10, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3438451, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:adamwill edited this update.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] New build(s):
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] - grub2-2.06-118.fc39
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] Removed build(s):
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] - grub2-2.06-117.fc39
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] Karma has been reset., timestamp:2024-03-05 20:04:06, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]], [id:3438452, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This update has been submitted for testing by adamwill. , timestamp:2024-03-05 20:04:07, update_id:591513, user_id:91, bug_feedback:[], testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:91, name:bodhi, email:null, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[]]]], builds:[[nvr:grub2-2.06-118.fc39, signed:false, release_id:70, type:rpm, epoch:0]], bugs:[[bug_id:2256827, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users, security:true, parent:true, feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3438438, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3438438, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:@nfrayer said he would add a fix for the XFS issue, but I don't see it yet., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:57:04, update_id:591514, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3438439, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3438439, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:@nfrayer said he would add a fix for the XFS issue, but I don't see it yet., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:57:12, update_id:591513, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3438440, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3438440, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:Given that this is a security fix and doesn't make things worse than they are at present, let's waive the failures and get it pushed stable., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:58:27, update_id:591513, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3421192, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3421192, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:So, the reason this failed tests is a bit unique. They're failing on a sanity check in the openQA tests: it checks whether the test actually has a newer version of the package installed than is present in the update under test, and if so, it flags that as a problem. *Usually* what that means is that, somehow, a newer package already got pushed stable, and pushing the update-under-test stable would move the package backwards, but that's not how it is in this case.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] In this case, the openQA server base image is actually hacked up to use a grub2 build from a side repo (https://adamwill.fedorapeople.org/grubxfs-repo/ ), which I rather arbitrarily versioned grub2-2.06-118.fc39. So it's higher-versioned than the one in this update, so it triggers the failure.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] The reason why I'm doing that is https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=2259266 (which current affects F39). If I let the openQA server base image use the current stable grub2 package, it doesn't boot because of that bug.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] So...it would make things much easier if this update fixed that bug, is what I'm saying. :P Otherwise I'll have to do a hack like disabling the check just for this update so it can go through.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] I thought that bug was supposed to be getting fixed last week; what's the current status, @nfrayer ?, timestamp:2024-02-22 20:42:05, update_id:591513, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3421197, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3421197, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This fails tests for the same reason as the F39 update: https://bodhi.fedoraproject.org/updates/FEDORA-2024-097eb22907#comment-3421192 . Waiting to hear from @nfrayer before deciding what to do., timestamp:2024-02-22 20:53:07, update_id:591514, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3422085, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3422085, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:works, timestamp:2024-02-23 04:21:12, update_id:591513, user_id:5881, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:5881, name:geraldosimiao, email:geraldo.simiao.kutz@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ambassadors], [name:fedora-br], [name:advocates], [name:respins-sig]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3424708, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3424708, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:ok on bare metal, timestamp:2024-02-24 15:45:23, update_id:591514, user_id:4054, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:4054, name:boycottsystemd1, email:boycottsystemd@yahoo.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:ipausers]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3425131, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3425131, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:Working here OK., timestamp:2024-02-25 01:33:57, update_id:591513, user_id:4756, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:4756, name:nixuser, email:nixuser@mail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3426579, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3426579, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:, timestamp:2024-02-26 13:15:31, update_id:591513, user_id:2935, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:2935, name:imabug, email:eugenemah@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedora-hams]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3430974, bug_id:2256827, comment:[id:3430974, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:Ok on VM , timestamp:2024-02-29 14:42:52, update_id:591514, user_id:5881, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:5881, name:geraldosimiao, email:geraldo.simiao.kutz@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ambassadors], [name:fedora-br], [name:advocates], [name:respins-sig]]]]]]], [bug_id:2263036, title:CVE-2024-1048 grub2: grub2-set-bootflag can be abused by local (pseudo-)users [fedora-all], security:true, parent:false, feedback:[[karma:0, comment_id:3438438, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3438438, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:@nfrayer said he would add a fix for the XFS issue, but I don't see it yet., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:57:04, update_id:591514, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3438439, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3438439, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:@nfrayer said he would add a fix for the XFS issue, but I don't see it yet., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:57:12, update_id:591513, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3438440, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3438440, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:Given that this is a security fix and doesn't make things worse than they are at present, let's waive the failures and get it pushed stable., timestamp:2024-03-05 19:58:27, update_id:591513, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3421192, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3421192, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:So, the reason this failed tests is a bit unique. They're failing on a sanity check in the openQA tests: it checks whether the test actually has a newer version of the package installed than is present in the update under test, and if so, it flags that as a problem. *Usually* what that means is that, somehow, a newer package already got pushed stable, and pushing the update-under-test stable would move the package backwards, but that's not how it is in this case.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] In this case, the openQA server base image is actually hacked up to use a grub2 build from a side repo (https://adamwill.fedorapeople.org/grubxfs-repo/ ), which I rather arbitrarily versioned grub2-2.06-118.fc39. So it's higher-versioned than the one in this update, so it triggers the failure.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] The reason why I'm doing that is https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=2259266 (which current affects F39). If I let the openQA server base image use the current stable grub2 package, it doesn't boot because of that bug.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] So...it would make things much easier if this update fixed that bug, is what I'm saying. :P Otherwise I'll have to do a hack like disabling the check just for this update so it can go through.
20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z]20:04:21[2024-03-05T20:04:21.888Z] I thought that bug was supposed to be getting fixed last week; what's the current status, @nfrayer ?, timestamp:2024-02-22 20:42:05, update_id:591513, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3421197, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3421197, karma:0, karma_critpath:0, text:This fails tests for the same reason as the F39 update: https://bodhi.fedoraproject.org/updates/FEDORA-2024-097eb22907#comment-3421192 . Waiting to hear from @nfrayer before deciding what to do., timestamp:2024-02-22 20:53:07, update_id:591514, user_id:302, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:302, name:adamwill, email:awilliam@redhat.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:proventesters], [name:provenpackager], [name:packager], [name:qa-tools-sig], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:news], [name:gittriage], [name:sysadmin], [name:gitspin-kickstarts], [name:signed_fpca], [name:gitgeneric-release], [name:yak_farmers], [name:triagers], [name:qa], [name:sysadmin-qa], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ipausers], [name:gitmkinitrd], [name:qa-admin], [name:aws-qa], [name:change-wranglers], [name:fedora-ci-admins], [name:sysadmin-main], [name:gitfedora-project-schedule], [name:common-issues-triage], [name:program-management]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3422085, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3422085, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:works, timestamp:2024-02-23 04:21:12, update_id:591513, user_id:5881, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:5881, name:geraldosimiao, email:geraldo.simiao.kutz@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ambassadors], [name:fedora-br], [name:advocates], [name:respins-sig]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3424708, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3424708, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:ok on bare metal, timestamp:2024-02-24 15:45:23, update_id:591514, user_id:4054, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:4054, name:boycottsystemd1, email:boycottsystemd@yahoo.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:ipausers]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3425131, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3425131, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:Working here OK., timestamp:2024-02-25 01:33:57, update_id:591513, user_id:4756, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:4756, name:nixuser, email:nixuser@mail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3426579, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3426579, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:, timestamp:2024-02-26 13:15:31, update_id:591513, user_id:2935, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:2935, name:imabug, email:eugenemah@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedora-hams]]]]], [karma:0, comment_id:3430974, bug_id:2263036, comment:[id:3430974, karma:1, karma_critpath:0, text:Ok on VM , timestamp:2024-02-29 14:42:52, update_id:591514, user_id:5881, testcase_feedback:[], user:[id:5881, name:geraldosimiao, email:geraldo.simiao.kutz@gmail.com, avatar:null, openid:null, groups:[[name:qa], [name:ipausers], [name:fedora-contributor], [name:signed_fpca], [name:fedorabugs], [name:ambassadors], [name:fedora-br], [name:advocates], [name:respins-sig]]]]]]]], updateid:FEDORA-2024-097eb22907, karma:0, content_type:rpm, test_cases:[]]]
![[Jenkins]](/static/5488d8ee/images/svgs/logo.svg){kind=logo}
